For various reasons that are always questioned by conservatives, I served as an AmeriCorps VISTA for two years after college. I don’t regret it. I worked with an amazing nonprofit in Chattanooga that made my first two years in the professional world a dream.
However, I was clued into a new universe of “community organizing” that veered dangerously close to socialism and was funded by taxpayer dollars. This experience is one of the main reasons I’m so conservative today. I’ve worked in the liberal world and seen firsthand how those programs and policies fail time after time.
Since I’m an AmeriCorps alumni, I get all of the emails from Voices for National Service, the lobbying group affiliated with the Corporation for National and Community Service (CNCS). The one they sent this week was truly nauseating:
Tell Us How Senator Kennedy Has Impacted Your Life
Video reel to be shown at event marking one-year anniversary of Serve America Act
On April 21, 2010, we will celebrate the first anniversary of the signing of the Edward M. Kennedy Serve America Act. This legislation authorized the largest increase in national service opportunities since the New Deal, tapping the energy and ingenuity of our citizens to address today’s critical problems.
To mark the one-year anniversary and honor Senator Kennedy’s unyielding dedication to our cause, a video is being compiled with stories of lives touched and changed by service. Our partners at ServiceNation are collecting brief video testimonials, and the final tribute will be shown at an anniversary event in Washington, DC.
Remember the Serve America Act? In addition to passing the Stimulus and now health care, the government expanded taxpayer subsidized volunteers, costing you and me a little more than $1 billion. Keep in mind, these volunteers are overwhelmingly the type who believe Ted Kennedy was an honorable American. (There’s ZERO political diversity among AmeriCorps types.)
I only wish that memorializing Teddy was the worst part. Voices for National Service, NCCS and other groups are thrilled that once again, President Obama has asked for an expansion of their funding for FY 2011.
Yep, the Prez wants to expand paid volunteerism in a year of out-of-control spending by 23%. According to Voices:
On February 1, 2010, President Obama released his Administration’s budget for fiscal year 2011, including $1.416 billion for the Corporation for National and Community Service (CNCS). This is an increase of $266 million or 23.1% above the FY 2010 enacted level.
Voices for National Service even published this nifty graph to show us the dramatic increase:

I’m all for helping people. I’ve slaved at nonprofits and still spend the majority of my free time volunteering for various causes. I also try to give as much as my income away that I can. However, these programs do not work. VISTA launched in 1965 to expressly fight the “war on poverty.” We’re nearly 50 years into the war, and nothing has improved.
Sadly, when federal funding increases, and with it taxes, private philanthropic donations decrease. Rather than support some bureaucrats “genius” idea (who has likely never worked outside of the Beltway) with my non-voluntary tax dollars, I’d rather give freely to grassroots programs that are actually working.
The key out of poverty isn’t welfare programs, food stamps, or government grants. The key is jobs, hard work and education. There are success stories, but with all of the money being thrown at these programs, we should be overwhelmed by the success of the programs from the past five decades. Big government programs don’t work and never will.
Think about where that money is going. Hardly any of it will actually help people. Most of it will go toward administrative costs and scholarships. Programs like VISTA are administered by a federal layer, which works with a state layer, which works with a local layer, which actually supervises the work of the volunteers.
All those in between layers are living pretty nice. Recent reports show that federal employees make an average of $10,680 more than private sector. Also realize that entry-level workers at the NCCS, start out around around $40,000.
Very little of Obama’s proposed $1.4 billion will actually help people in need. Most of it will go to hire mid-level bureaucrats who think Teddy Kennedy is awesome! Wouldn’t it be better to give Americans a 23% tax cut, so that we can actually write checks to nonprofits that feed homeless people or teach kids how to read?
Click here to read about my initial reaction to AmeriCorps training back in 2004.